This old-school New York diner offers a huge selection of delicious sandwiches. Our favorite? The Turkey Reuben. Toss it back with some fries and a milk-shake and you'll find yourself waddling out contentedly. And vegetarians? Take heart; they've got a veggie burger, grilled cheese, PB&J, and enough other options to make you say "mmm."
174 5th Avenue between 22nd and 23rd Sts; 212-675-5096; N, R, W to 23rd St.

